Q: Our householders affiliation on Lengthy Island has determined unilaterally to take out a seven-figure mortgage to revamp the leisure amenities. To repay it, the board is diverting our annual assessments away from their meant function of funding reserves to restore crumbling roads and curbs. We haven’t requested for these initiatives, and didn’t obtain something in writing about them. Our governing paperwork don’t require the board to hunt approval earlier than borrowing, and don’t put limits on how a lot the board can borrow. What can we do?
A: In a householders’ affiliation, the board of administrators is elected to make selections for the neighborhood, and this usually contains borrowing for renovations. No matter the advantages of the HOA association, there’s little you are able to do in a scenario like this.
“If you transfer into an affiliation, you surrender sure rights and are submitting to sure powers of the board as set forth within the governing paperwork,” mentioned Marc H. Schneider, an actual property lawyer on Lengthy Island.
If board members are performing in accordance along with your governing paperwork, and they’re making selections in good religion, then they’re protected against legal responsibility by way of a authorized precept referred to as the enterprise judgment rule. Borrowing to renovate the neighborhood’s leisure amenities is often permissible in associations’ governing paperwork, and can be an motion thought of in good religion.
If you happen to have been in a apartment, it might be a unique story. Condominiums in New York are ruled by a regulation requiring that unit house owners vote on all borrowing. Boards can not borrow unilaterally, except the bylaws include that proper.
There are two elements of your HOA’s mission that might doubtlessly contravene the governing paperwork, providing you with a authorized declare: First, whether or not the board is including new facilities that didn’t exist earlier than. And second, whether or not the paperwork permit using annual assessments for the mortgage reimbursement to fund the renovations (which isn’t an uncommon observe).
“The governing paperwork needs to be fastidiously reviewed to find out if the board is exceeding its powers,” Mr. Schneider mentioned.
As all the time, collective motion along with your neighbors can change the course of your neighborhood. “Why not simply run for the board in opposition to these board members if you happen to disagree with the allocation of funds, and use that as your platform?” mentioned Andrew Lieb, an actual property lawyer on Lengthy Island.
For weekly electronic mail updates on residential actual property information, join right here.
