FatCamera
Funding Thesis
The funding potential of Excessive Tide (NASDAQ:HITI) lies in its risk to be a long-term compounder, pushed by the strategic allocation of free money movement towards the enlargement of recent shops. Thereby realizing extra free money movement to have the funds to open shops at a good greater tempo. Within the subsequent sections, I am going to elaborate on the rationale behind my confidence in Excessive Tide’s means to generate more and more extra free money movement over the next years. And moreover, I’ll assess the corporate utilizing Chuck Akre’s three-legged stool framework to find out if it meets the factors of a high quality enterprise.
Introduction
Excessive Tide is Canada’s high revenue-generating hashish firm with over 168 brick-and-mortar retail areas and several other worldwide hashish e-commerce platforms, boasting an annual income run fee exceeding $500 million CAD. Within the final two quarters’ earnings calls Excessive Tide’s CEO gave some particular numbers on the prices of development, which supplies me the likelihood to calculate what sort of returns the corporate could make whereas executing on this development. Within the subsequent paragraphs, I’ll consider Excessive Tide’s funding potential on the idea of Chuck Akre’s theoretical funding framework, notably specializing in the three-legged-stool method. Chuck Akre’s three-legged stool mannequin emphasizes investing in firms with a excessive return on invested capital (ROIC), sustainable development potential and robust administration groups. By analyzing Excessive Tide’s enterprise mannequin, development methods, and monetary efficiency by way of the lens of Akre’s ideas, I goal to supply a complete evaluation of its means to compound worth over the long run.
Strategic Shift
At first of 2023, Excessive Tide launched into a strategic shift prioritizing the technology of free money movement over fast-paced development. This deliberate transfer aimed to strengthen the corporate’s monetary resilience and, extra importantly, present a self-sustaining mechanism for future development. By producing free money movement the corporate can fund the opening of recent shops by itself with out being depending on exterior funding (both by way of fairness or debt). Notably, this strategic initiative bore fruit within the final three quarters, with Excessive Tide efficiently producing 4.1 million Canadian {dollars} in free money movement in FQ3 2023, 5.7 million in FQ4 2023 and three.6 million in FQ1 2024. This totals north of 13 million Canadian {dollars} within the final three quarters. This accomplishment highlights the corporate’s dedication to sensible operational and value administration and units them up properly to fund future development plans utilizing their very own sources.
Current Quarters’ Money Flows
In a notable monetary efficiency within the final three reported monetary quarters, Excessive Tide demonstrated a commendable free money movement margin of three.3%, 4.48% and a couple of.81% respectively. The conclusion we will draw from that is that the corporate is making substantial progress in executing its strategic shift.
Quarter 23FQ1 23FQ2 23FQ3 23FQ4 24FQ1 Income 118M 119.1M 124.4M 127.1M 128.1M Adjusted EBITDA 5.5M 6.6M 10.2M 8.4M 10.4M Adjusted EBITDA Margin 4.66% 5.6% 8.2% 6.61% 8.12% FCF -0.8M -2M 4.1M 5.7M 3.6M FCF Margin -0.68% -1.69% 3.3% 4.48% 2.81% Click on to enlarge
Nonetheless, these margins stay comparatively modest, primarily as a result of Excessive Tide being within the early phases of attaining profitability. However this additionally signifies that the corporate nonetheless has a considerable runway for vital margin enlargement sooner or later. The corporate is strategically positioned for margin enchancment by way of a few key avenues. Firstly, the cultivation of higher-margin income streams, notably the Cabana ELITE paid membership program, the gross sales of knowledge by way of their cabanalytics platform, and the rollout of white label merchandise, which is predicted to contribute increasingly within the coming quarters. The Cabana ELITE membership program gives shoppers engaging reductions whereas offering the corporate with secure income streams. Moreover, the easy legal guidelines economies of scale, pushed by a considerable improve in retailer depend over the following two to a few years, will probably improve each free money movement and adjusted EBITDA margins. In FQ4’s earnings name, Excessive Tide’s CEO Raj Grover projected that between 20-30 new shops might be operational by the tip of 2024:
Our expectation is to open 20 to 30 shops in calendar 2024 by way of a mixture of natural builds and M&Some time remaining free money movement constructive.
Lastly, Excessive Tide’s administration workforce has demonstrated efficient price administration prior to now 4 quarters, showcasing their functionality to navigate the evolving panorama of the hashish retail sector and optimize profitability within the firm’s toddler phases.
Flat working prices whereas rising considerably (Excessive Tide)
As seen above, working prices remained unchanged year-over-year within the final full reported 12 months ending on October thirty first, whereas each income and gross revenue elevated by 37% and 30%, respectively. That is spectacular, to say the least, and precisely the way you need to see an organization rising. Moreover, with considerably rising revenues anticipated over the following two years, absolutely the amount of money the corporate will generate is poised to extend considerably if it may handle to maintain the working bills beneath management.
You will need to state that a big quantity (if not all) of the reported free money movement is generated by the gross sales of knowledge by way of Excessive Tide’s cabanalytics platform (excessive margin income of respectively 6.5M, 6.8M and seven.3M within the final three reported quarters). Once I examine all of the numbers I believe the brick-and-mortar shops don’t generate free money movement by themselves but, I believe they’re kind of money movement break even. Nonetheless, I believe it is important to not view the brick-and-mortar shops in isolation. As an alternative, I believe a holistic method that considers Excessive Tide’s complete enterprise ecosystem—together with brick-and-mortar shops, e-commerce platforms, paid memberships, and knowledge gross sales—is warranted. I personally view it as an interconnected ecosystem that each wants but additionally amplifies one another. The high-margin knowledge enterprise and the paid membership program can solely exist by advantage of the prevailing large-scale retailer community. That’s to say, the high-margin knowledge enterprise and the income generated from paid memberships are reliant on the prevailing large-scale retailer community. This interconnectedness signifies that the expansion of the shop community contributes to the general worth of the ecosystem. In consequence, the information turns into extra invaluable, and the pool of potential paid memberships grows, in the end impacting the underside line positively. This built-in view underscores the strategic significance of every facet of Excessive Tide’s enterprise and the way they amplify one another’s worth inside the broader ecosystem. And, as well as, I imagine it demonstrates that though the brick-and-mortar shops don’t straight generate money by themselves but, the expansion of Excessive Tide’s retailer community not directly contributes considerably to the corporate’s backside line by way of the worth they ship to the whole ecosystem.
ROIC
One of many elementary ideas inside Chuck Akre’s three-legged stool framework is the popularity that the standard of a enterprise, amongst different components, is set by its means to realize a excessive Return on Invested Capital (ROIC). Within the case of Excessive Tide, this precept holds vital weight as we assess the corporate’s efficiency and potential for long-term worth creation. Calculating the ROIC sheds gentle on the effectivity with which Excessive Tide makes use of its capital to generate income, thus providing invaluable insights into the standard of its operations and capital allocation methods. With a median free money movement margin over the past three reported quarters of three.53% and CEO Raj Grover’s disclosures concerning retailer efficiency and enlargement prices, we will calculate Excessive Tide’s ROIC.
If we think about the typical free money movement margin of the final two reported quarters, which stands at 3.53%, we will calculate absolutely the quantity of free money movement generated by a median retailer. Whereas this calculation could in a roundabout way illustrate the money movement from particular person shops, it supplies an estimation of the extra money that can movement by way of the whole ecosystem as a result of worth added by increasing the shop community, as defined above. Within the FQ4 2023 earnings name, CEO Raj Grover acknowledged that the typical retailer in Ontario generated 3.6 million, and in Alberta, it was 2.2 million. Let’s take a conservative method, contemplating Excessive Tide at the moment has 59 of its 168 shops in Ontario, and calculate the typical between these two figures, which is roughly 2.5 million. With a free money movement margin of three.53%, the typical comparatively mature retailer is estimated so as to add worth equal to round 88k in free money movement per 12 months to Excessive Tide’s ecosystem. CEO Grover additionally acknowledged that the typical price of opening up new shops is 300K (excluding the money that needs to be made free for working capital), a easy calculation states that the return on the invested capital of opening a brand new retailer is simply shy of 30%. If we additionally embrace the distinction in working capital (100K, additionally acknowledged within the FQ4 earnings name) inside the invested capital, the ROIC continues to be 22%.
It is essential to notice that not all at the moment opened shops have reached a mature standing and might not be working at optimum profitability but. On the similar time, we additionally should understand that Excessive Tide’s historical past of money technology spans simply three quarters, so we additionally should take present free money movement margins with a grain of salt. The longer they keep constructive and might enhance, the extra worth we will attribute to them. Reaching an ROIC of twenty-two% for a corporation on this early stage of profitability could be very spectacular in both case. This may be attributed to the truth that, in contrast to conventional brick-and-mortar companies, Excessive Tide operates their brick-and-mortar shops comparatively capital gentle. They do not personal the land and shops; as an alternative, they lease them at favorable costs as a result of their scale. For opening new shops, it is only a matter of rebuilding the shop house and shopping for stock. One other issue contributing to their excessive ROIC is, as defined above, I believe that their retailer community amplifies a few of their higher-margin income streams. By opening a brand new retailer, they not solely generate money by way of the shop counter but additionally leverage the elevated worth of their retailer community by way of knowledge gross sales. These income streams are extra worthwhile than the classical retail enterprise, not directly boosting their ROIC.
Excessive Tide’s spectacular ROIC signifies that the corporate passes one of many three legs of Chuck Akre’s stool framework. This robust monetary efficiency displays Excessive Tide’s sensible use of capital and environment friendly operations, that are key components Akre seems to be for in high quality companies. Excessive Tide’s means to ship stable returns on its invested capital suggests it has the potential for long-term development and success, becoming nicely into Akre’s funding ideas.
Progress Alternative
The second leg of Chuck Akre’s stool framework is all about an organization’s means to reinvest its earnings successfully. This implies discovering alternatives the place income could be plowed again into the enterprise to gas future development and worth creation. Akre emphasizes the significance of companies with the ability to use their earnings correctly to generate excessive returns, which in the end results in long-term wealth creation for buyers. This give attention to reinvestment highlights the importance of firms having a transparent technique for deploying their income again into the enterprise to drive sustained development over time. As Akre writes in one in all his funding letters:
Over a interval of years, our pondering has targeted increasingly on the difficulty of reinvestment as the one most crucial ingredient in a profitable funding concept, upon getting already recognized an excellent enterprise.
I believe Excessive Tide meets this situation. Excessive Tide runs a really scalable enterprise. By opening up new shops in an space the place potential shoppers dwell who haven’t got entry to hashish merchandise (or the low cost mannequin of Excessive Tide itself) but, they’ll attain a brand new buyer base. In Canada alone, there are nonetheless lots underpenetrated areas and subsequently potential prospects to succeed in. As well as, current regulatory shifts, such because the doubling of the shop cap in Ontario from 75 to 150 shops, permit the corporate to develop considerably in its most worthwhile market. Excessive Tide at the moment has the goal to succeed in 300 shops in Canada within the subsequent few years (from 168 at the moment), however I personally am satisfied there’s room for ample additional development behind this milestone. The legalized hashish enterprise in Canada continues to be in its infancy, when the consumption of hashish merchandise has reached a extra mature state of social and cultural acceptance I believe a penetration of greater than the present 8% is viable. In conclusion, I believe in Canada alone the corporate can develop to greater than double their dimension within the subsequent three to 4 years.
Furthermore, the anticipated regulatory adjustments in each Germany and the USA maintain the promise of unlocking a complete new stage of market alternatives for Excessive Tide. Only in the near past Germany accepted legal guidelines making hashish authorized for leisure use. Though the nation has not opened the gates but for industrial gross sales, the plans are that it’ll occur in 2025. With Germany having greater than double the quantity of residents compared to Canada, the chance could be large. As well as, the USA additionally presents a doubtlessly large alternative for Excessive Tide. Presently, Nasdaq laws stop them from doing precise hashish enterprise in the USA, however with the passage of the SAFER banking act this might change. When the principles allow them to function, the expansion potential is seemingly boundless. I view each the US and Germany as option-type alternatives, however vital ones.
Excessive Tide’s thrilling development prospects sign its adherence to the second of the pillars of Chuck Akre’s funding philosophy. This outlook displays Excessive Tide’s means to scale up and seize alternatives out there with their money flows, qualities that Akre values in robust companies. With its potential for enlargement, Excessive Tide aligns nicely with Akre’s method, which emphasizes long-term development and worth creation for its shareholders.
Funding of Progress
As acknowledged above, the corporate desires to broaden the shop depend with 20 to 30 shops in calendar 12 months 2024. This can price the corporate 6M to 9M and an extra 2M to 3M in working capital that needs to be added to the steadiness sheet. If we extrapolate the 13.3M free money movement of the final three reported quarters to the complete 12 months, we get a yearly free money movement of 17.9M. Probably the most aggressive aim of opening 30 shops can, if we depart from the figures the corporate offered in FQ4 earnings name, simply be funded from the present free money movement. And, as well as, the corporate has additionally money left for different strategic development investments apart from opening up new shops or debt reimbursement. The present development plan with regard to opening up new shops can, thereby, be seen as conservative. As free money movement grows as a result of rising worth of their ecosystem, I believe the corporate can simply improve the tempo of opening new shops to an quantity of fifty to 70 per 12 months within the subsequent 2 to three years. Roughly talking, it will price the corporate 15M to 21M in opening prices and an extra 5M to 7M of working capital that needs to be made free. My estimation is that, with the extra money flows generated from current retailer openings and people deliberate within the close to future, the power to fund the opening of 70 new shops per 12 months solely from free money movement will not be too far-off. Contemplating this, it is essential to notice that the corporate at the moment operates 168 shops. With the potential means to fund the opening of 70 new shops per 12 months from free money movement alone, this means the potential for a 40% improve from the present whole retailer depend inside one 12 months, with out requiring any exterior funding.
Administration
The third and final leg of Chuck Akre’s three-legged stool considers the administration. Though there’s not an enormous observe file to guage Excessive Tide’s administration, it’s sure that, beneath the management of Raj Grover, the administration has demonstrated glimpses of remarkable high quality and lots confidence. It has led the corporate from an annual income of 10M to a present run fee of virtually half a billion in beneath 5 years. This 50x is spectacular, to say the least. With regard to profitability, the administration workforce efficiently turned the enterprise round from a fast-growing however loss-making entity to 1 that generates free money movement when market circumstances modified. I believe this swift transformation displays the power to execute operational enhancements successfully. Moreover, Raj Grover’s substantial private funding in Excessive Tide, holding over 8% of the corporate’s shares, underscores his alignment with shareholders. His current further share purchases, together with different insiders, additional spotlight their alignment with shareholders’ pursuits and their perception within the firm’s long-term potential. This mix of forward-thinking technique, efficient operational techniques, and substantial private dedication aligns completely with the wonderful administration leg of Chuck Akre’s three-legged stool. All in all, I believe Excessive Tide’s administration is on observe to show themselves to be wonderful stewards working for shareholders’ pursuits.
Valuation
If we begin from a ROIC of barely greater than 20%, I believe a present free money movement a number of of at the least 25 is totally warranted with an organization with this vital development forward. A really conservative yearly free money movement of 15M would make for a present market cap of 375M Canadian {dollars}. With the current run-up on the day of writing (sixth of April), the corporate at the moment trades at a market cap of round 275M Canadian {dollars}. For my part, there’s nonetheless 25% upside to succeed in the present truthful worth. As the corporate grows and extra shops attain a mature standing, I believe the yearly free money movement will exceed 15M by a big extent. Once they attain their present aim of 300 shops in Canada, and a free money movement margin of 5% (which ought to be simply achievable on a bigger scale), a free money movement of at the least 43.5M is achievable. When that is the case, the share value may simply 3x from present ranges to a market cap of practically 900M Canadian {dollars}. I’ll personally observe the corporate’s execution and see in the event that they’re in a position to proceed their development and enhance their profitability. If that’s the case, I see no issues reaching the 900M valuation within the subsequent three years. Once they’re in a position to function in both Germany or the US, I should reevaluate, as a result of the potential for development and shareholder returns may attain a lot greater ranges.
Conclusion
With notable strides in current quarters, characterised by substantial free money movement technology and considered price administration, Excessive Tide is poised for sustained development. The corporate’s formidable enlargement plans, alongside potential regulatory landscapes each domestically and internationally, may pave the way in which for promising alternatives forward. Moreover, upon analysis in opposition to Chuck Akre’s three-legged stool framework, Excessive Tide demonstrates alignment with all key standards, which qualifies it as a high quality enterprise. Nonetheless, for the reason that observe file of the corporate – particularly concerning profitability – will not be that lengthy, we nonetheless want to watch the corporate quarter by quarter to make sure that its execution stays constant.
