How North Korean eyelashes make their method to West as ‘made in China’ By Reuters

By Ju-min Park and Eduardo Baptista

SEOUL/PINGDU, China (Reuters) – Hundreds of thousands of {dollars} in gross sales of North Korean false eyelashes – marketed in magnificence shops around the globe as “made in China” – helped drive a restoration within the secretive state’s exports final yr.

The processing and packaging of North Korean false eyelashes – brazenly carried out in neighbouring China, the nation’s largest buying and selling accomplice – provides Kim Jong Un’s regime a method to skirt worldwide sanctions, offering an important supply of international foreign money.

Reuters spoke to twenty individuals – together with 15 within the eyelash business, in addition to commerce legal professionals and consultants on North Korea’s financial system – who described a system by which China-based corporations import semi-finished merchandise from North Korea, that are then accomplished and packaged as Chinese language.

The completed eyelashes are then exported to markets together with the West, Japan and South Korea, based on eight individuals who work for firms straight concerned within the commerce.

A few of the individuals spoke provided that solely their final names be used as a result of they weren’t authorised to speak to the media.

North Korea has lengthy been a significant exporter of hair merchandise like wigs and false lashes, which allow individuals to keep away from the trouble of mascara and to realize a dramatic look. However exports tumbled throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, when North Korea slammed its borders tightly shut.

Important commerce in North Korea-made lashes by way of China resumed in 2023, based on customs paperwork and 4 individuals within the business.

Chinese language customs knowledge confirmed that North Korea’s exports to China greater than doubled in 2023, when borders reopened. China is the vacation spot for practically all of North Korea’s declared exports.

Wigs and eyelashes comprised nearly 60% of declared North Korean exports to China final yr. In complete, North Korea exported 1,680 tonnes of false eyelashes, beards and wigs to China in 2023, price round $167 million.

In 2019, when costs have been decrease, it exported 1,829 tonnes at a price of simply $31.1 million.

The U.S. State Division and worldwide consultants estimate that North Korea seizes as much as 90% of international revenue generated by its residents, lots of whom stay in poverty. Reuters was unable to find out how a lot of the income from eyelash gross sales flowed again to Kim’s authorities, or the way it was used. 

“We have now to imagine that … hundreds of thousands of {dollars} each month that North Korea is making by way of this eyelash commerce is getting used for the Kim Jong Un regime,” mentioned Seoul-based sanctions lawyer Shin Tong-chan. His view was corroborated by two different worldwide commerce consultants, although none offered particular proof.

North Korea didn’t reply to requests for remark for this story despatched to its U.N. missions in New York and Geneva, its embassy in Beijing and its consular workplace within the Chinese language border metropolis of Dandong.

A spokesperson for the Chinese language International Ministry mentioned Beijing and Pyongyang “are pleasant neighbors” and that “regular cooperation between the 2 international locations that’s lawful and compliant shouldn’t be exaggerated.”

U.N. AND U.S. SANCTIONS

Since 2006, the United Nations Safety Council has sought to stall Pyongyang’s nuclear weapons programme by way of practically a dozen sanctions resolutions that limit its skill to commerce merchandise equivalent to coal, textiles and oil. It additionally imposed strict restrictions on North Koreans working overseas.

Sanctions handed by the Safety Council are purported to be enforced by U.N. member states – all of whom are legally certain to implement them – utilizing native laws.

However there isn’t any direct ban on hair merchandise, so buying and selling false eyelashes from North Korea doesn’t essentially violate worldwide legislation, three sanctions consultants instructed Reuters.

Reuters introduced its findings to the Chinese language International Ministry, which mentioned it was “not conscious of the circumstances” described however that any alleged violations of U.N. sanctions are “fully with out basis”.

Japan’s international ministry didn’t touch upon Reuters’ findings, however mentioned Tokyo, which bans commerce with Pyongyang, would proceed to think about “the simplest strategy” towards North Korea. The European Union’s diplomatic service didn’t return requests for touch upon North Korean-made eyelashes being offered in its jurisdiction.

America has since 2008 individually expanded its personal measures towards North Korea, which embody sanctions on any firm stocking or promoting merchandise whose gross sales fund the Kim regime: a restriction that additionally applies to non-American corporations utilizing the U.S. greenback.

However there are sensible and political limitations on Washington’s skill to implement such sanctions unilaterally on entities equivalent to international companies which have minimal publicity to the U.S. monetary system and do not promote primarily to American shoppers, based on two worldwide sanctions legal professionals.

A U.S. Treasury spokesperson mentioned it “actively enforces the vary of our broad North Korea sanctions authorities towards each U.S. and international corporations” and would “proceed to aggressively goal any income technology efforts” by Pyongyang.

The Treasury additionally referenced its practically $1 million settlement with e.l.f. Cosmetics in 2019 over allegations that the U.S.-based agency inadvertently offered false eyelashes containing supplies from North Korea.

e.l.f.’s father or mother firm mentioned in a 2019 submitting that it found two suppliers had used North Korean supplies throughout a “routine, self-administered audit” and that it rapidly addressed the difficulty, which it decided was “not materials.”

The corporate, which has since stopped promoting false eyelashes, reiterated its dedication to creating merchandise legally and responsibly in a press release to Reuters for this story.

Reuters was unable to determine whether or not any Western firms are at present concerned within the North Korean eyelash commerce.

CHINA’S ‘EYELASH CAPITAL OF THE WORLD’

The individuals concerned within the business mentioned that Pingdu, an japanese Chinese language city that payments itself the ‘eyelash capital of the world’, is a key node within the provide chain from North Korea.

Many Pingdu-based firms, equivalent to Monsheery, bundle false eyelashes which might be produced primarily by North Koreans, mentioned Wang Tingting, whose household owns the agency, which exports merchandise to the U.S., Brazil and Russia.

Wang mentioned in an interview from her manufacturing unit that North Korean items had helped construct Monsheery up from a small household workshop. The corporate was based in 2015, company data present.

“The standard of the North Korean product is a lot better,” mentioned Wang, who mentioned that she was not conscious of any sanctions-related points with utilizing North Korean false eyelashes. She declined to call her worldwide shoppers.

Others in Pingdu mentioned they’re aware of the position sanctions play within the sophisticated distribution chain.

“If not for these sanctions, there could be no want for (North Koreans) to export by way of China,” mentioned Gao, who owns Yumuhui Eyelash. 

Cui Huzhe, who represents a North Korean manufacturing unit that works with a Chinese language accomplice in a enterprise referred to as the Korea-China Processing Joint Buying and selling Firm, mentioned the North Korean agency sends semi-finished eyelashes to China, the place they’re offered to markets together with the U.S., Europe, Japan and South Korea.

He declined to determine the 2 firms concerned within the partnership or their shoppers. Subsequently, he could not be reached for touch upon the sanctions implications.

INCOME FOR A CASH-STRAPPED STATE

Chinese language producers started working with North Korean eyelash vegetation within the early 2000s, based on three Chinese language manufacturing unit managers. They mentioned they prize the nation’s labour pressure for its low price and the top quality of the eyelashes.

About 80% of Pingdu’s eyelash factories buy or course of false eyelash uncooked supplies and semi-finished merchandise from North Korea, based on a 2023 estimate revealed by Kali, a Chinese language producer of eyelash containers, on its web site. 

Pingdu’s authorities says the city of roughly 1.2 million accounts for 70% of world output of false eyelashes, which are sometimes fabricated from artificial fibres however may additionally be created from mink fur or human hair.

Buying and selling firm Asia Pacific Worldwide Community Expertise, primarily based within the Chinese language border metropolis of Hunchun, advertises on its web site the providers of three North Korean eyelash processing factories with photographs of employees arranging hairs and pasting them on paper.

Reached by telephone, an organization worker, who wouldn’t give her identify, declined to remark.

Seoul-based businessman Johny Lee imports merchandise like chicken-feet formed lashes used for extensions by way of Dandong into South Korea.

These lashes are made by North Koreans, packaged in China, after which offered regionally or exported to Asian international locations like Japan, mentioned Lee, who chairs a commerce group in Seoul that features eyelash extension technicians from the West and South Korea.

Requested about authorized dangers, Lee – who started sourcing eyelashes from China a decade in the past – mentioned he was not promoting “refined know-how like semiconductors.” North Korean employees “try to make a dwelling there,” he mentioned.

South Korean legislation states that if two or extra international locations are concerned within the manufacturing of imported items, the place the place the merchandise gained “important traits” shall be deemed the nation of origin.

Reuters described how eyelashes made by North Korean employees are packaged and accomplished in China to Shin Min-ho, a South Korea-certified customs lawyer. He mentioned North Korea would doubtless be thought-about their nation of origin as a result of it gave the uncooked supplies “important traits.”

Seoul’s Korea Customs Companies mentioned that “importing North Korean merchandise disguised as Chinese language might be punished,” however that it was “troublesome to find out” nation of origin primarily based solely on Reuters’ description of the provision chain between North Korea and China and that it was not investigating the difficulty.

GOOD QUALITY, CHEAP SALARIES 

Regardless of the standard of the eyelashes, North Korean labour is poorly paid. North Korean salaries generally is a tenth of Chinese language wages, 4 Chinese language manufacturing unit homeowners and managers mentioned.

As well as, Wang, a supervisor for Pingdu-based producer Co-Lash, which ceased North Korean operations throughout the pandemic, mentioned the employees gave up most of their revenue to the state. He did not provide proof.

One other Chinese language producer, PD Lush, pays employees at its manufacturing unit within the North Korean border city of Rason – whose work is offered internationally – a mean month-to-month wage of 300 yuan ($42), mentioned Pingdu-based supervisor Wang. 

The centrality of North Korea to the business grew to become clear when the nation’s borders closed throughout the pandemic.

Monsheery’s Wang Tingting mentioned that after North Korea closed its borders in 2020 as a result of pandemic, ships carrying over the small quantity of eyelashes exported throughout that point have been typically held up. “We have now very excessive demand on our aspect,” she mentioned.

Within the wake of the pandemic, provide was nonetheless not at full capability and delivery delays have been frequent, she added.

South Korean false eyelash model Cinderella Amisolution sometimes procures provides from Chinese language merchants of semi-finished North Korean merchandise, which it then sells to clients. However when North Korea sealed its border, contractors despatched samples that weren’t made by North Koreans.

“I assumed, ‘this is not going to work’,” mentioned chief govt Choi Jee-won. “They have been fully completely different.”