Deepak Sethi/iStock through Getty Photos
Introduction
I’ve at all times favored Traders Title Firm (NASDAQ:ITIC) as I contemplate property title insurance coverage to be a low-risk enterprise. That is not only a private impression: the full quantity of provisions for claims is often only a fraction of the full quantity of the premium earnings. However in fact this additionally means ITIC’s efficiency is carefully tied to the housing market and the quantity of transactions as a property proprietor and/or mortgagee solely must insure the title upon a transaction. This additionally signifies that when mortgages charges are excessive and the full quantity of transactions is low, ITIC’s efficiency shall be struggling.
2023 shall be a comparatively weak 12 months for ITIC
Trying on the Q3 and 9M 2023 outcomes, the influence of the decrease transaction quantity on the actual property markets is very clear. The corporate reported a 25% decrease quantity of internet premiums written, however happily this additionally means the full fee payable to brokers got here in decrease as properly. The earnings assertion under exhibits a complete income of $61.4M of which the bulk is clearly generated by the title insurance coverage premiums. That being mentioned, ITIC is slowly benefiting from the growing rates of interest as its funding portfolio is doing fairly properly. The overall quantity of curiosity and dividends has doubled in comparison with the identical quarter of final 12 months and that undoubtedly helped to mitigate the influence of the decrease transaction volumes.
ITIC Investor Relations
The overall quantity of working bills did lower by simply over $15M, primarily because of a decrease fee expense and a barely decrease personnel expense along with decrease ‘different’ bills as properly. This resulted in a pre-tax earnings of $8.6M and a internet revenue of slightly below $7.1M. As there are slightly below 1.9M shares excellent, the web revenue per share was $3.75.
Trying on the 9M 2023 outcomes, the corporate generated an EPS of $8.37 which is simply barely decrease than the $8.63 in 9M 2022 however this might be defined by the $16.5M funding loss recorded within the first 9 months of final 12 months. Excluding that funding loss, ITIC’s pre-tax revenue would have been virtually 80% increased.
Traders Title pays a quarterly dividend of $0.46 per share but additionally has a behavior of paying a really beneficiant dividend within the last quarter of the 12 months when it has a greater thought of its monetary outcomes for the 12 months. Earlier this quarter, ITIC introduced a particular dividend of $4.00/share which can deliver the annualized dividend to $5.84 per share and this represents a dividend yield of 4%. Not unhealthy in what arguably is a really weak 12 months for mortgage and actual property transactions. Moreover, let’s not overlook the full-year EPS will possible are available at round $11-11.5/share (barren any unexpected surprises within the last quarter of the 12 months) which suggests the payout ratio is roughly 50%.
The rest of the revenue is retained on the steadiness sheet and as of the top of September, the corporate had a complete ebook worth of $252.7M representing virtually $134/share. This can drop by the top of this 12 months because the dividends payable in This autumn will possible be increased than the EPS.
ITIC Investor Relations
Goodwill and intangible account for $8.78 per share which suggests the tangible ebook worth per share is roughly $125 and I anticipate a year-end TBVPS of round $123/share after accounting for the particular dividend.
The corporate maintains a portfolio of securities and on the finish of September, it had about $65M in debt securities (marked to market as they’re held on an ‘accessible on the market’ foundation) and slightly below $32M in fairness securities. These are additionally marked to market as the unique price foundation of the securities is simply $19.4M.
Moreover, ITIC has virtually $104M in short-term investments which primarily consist of cash market accounts invested in short-term funds, US Treasury Payments and business paper.
Funding thesis
Given the low-risk nature of the title insurance coverage enterprise, I’m high quality paying 13 occasions earnings throughout a downcycle. As a reminder, the EPS in 2022 and 2021 was respectively $12.60 and $35.38, however each years had been impacted by substantial adjustments within the funding portfolio. Adjusting the EPS for these adjustments, the adjusted EPS in 2022 and 2021 would have been roughly $25.2 and $29.17/share.
And this makes ITIC one in every of my most popular autos to wager on decrease rates of interest and the next transaction quantity on the actual property markets. I at present haven’t any place in ITIC however shall be constructing my place within the subsequent few weeks and months.
